HomeResearch and NewsGermany Most Likely to Exit Euro
Opinion

Germany Most Likely to Exit Euro

Financial experts have been busy debating the possibility of Greece, Italy or Spain exiting the Eurozone, but what if the strongest member of the European Union simply refuses to keep paying for the debt crisis? In his column in business magazine Forbes, Golubovich outlines how the situation might develop if Germany exits the Eurozone instead. He writes: “The country that is, in effect, supporting the Euro, seems to need it the least. According to the results of a poll published by Bloomberg, around 40% of Germans are in favour of a Euro exit, while in other Eurozone countries this figure is much lower: 28% in Italy, 26% in France and 24% in Spain.”

Of course, if Germany chooses to exit, its economy and banks would suffer huge losses, since its financial institutions have around €2trn invested elsewhere in Europe. But the loss of personal savings by the German public can be avoided, Golubovich argues. He writes: “All current accounts in German banks denominated in Euros can be turned into Deutsche Marks at the same exchange rate as when Germany entered the Eurozone (1 Euro – 1.96 DM), or at a 1:1 ratio, which is more likely to avoid changing all the price tags.” As a result, the Germans would have a strong national currency.

The Euro would then deteriorate in value, while the strength of the new German currency would lead to a loss of competitive advantage for German exports. But the Bundesbank can intervene at this point to weaken the currency, Golubovich argues. In his eyes, this scenario looks more and more likely as the situation in the Eurozone deteriorates.

Otmar Issing, one of the founding fathers of the euro and a former European Central Bank chief economist, takes a different view. In his book “How We Save The Euro and Strengthen Europe”, published this week, he said: “Everything speaks in favour of savings the Euro area. How many countries will be part of it in the long term remains to be seen.” But if some of the peripheral countries may not be able to remain in the currency bloc, Germany’s exit would be bad news, he says.

Although he understands the nostalgia for the days of the Deutsche Mark felt by some of his fellow Germans, he warns against a return to the national currency. He writes: "Even in its short existence, the euro has been more stable than the mark.” Yet, like Angela Merkel, he opposes the idea of creating jointly issued Eurobonds, which for him “would mean the end of the stability-oriented currency union,” since Germany would have to carry the burden of eventually paying back the joint debt.

Golubovich argues that, if Germany stays in the Eurozone, it may be increasingly difficult for it to influence the decisions taken by the ECB. He points to the fact that Germany and its supporters – Austria, the Netherlands, France and Slovakia – now hold only six of the 23 votes on ECB’s board. All remaining members are either in favour of “turning on the printing press,” or at least not against it.

currencies, euro

Read more

Oil Market Report - March 2020

Crude oil prices ended February 2020 sharply lower with both ICE Brent and NYMEXWTI showing monthly declines of more than 12% to reach their lowest monthlyvalues in almost 2.5 years as the rapid spread of Covid-19 in China and several othercountries raised investors’ concerns about the impacts on the global economy and oildemand, and triggered a sharp sell-off in markets amid uncertainties on the extent ofdemand destruction and worries that this health crisis might evolve into a pandemic.

oil, investment, equity

Arbat Capital: Banking Sector Report - February 2020

US banks tumbled again in February after very weak performance in January amid spreading COVID-19 around the world. The broad market was underperformed substantially for the second consecutive month after 4 months in a row of leading dynamics. Thus, BKX index decreased by 12.5% MoM in February vs -8.4% MoM of SPX index. Absolute performance on MoM basis was -2 std from the mean and it is in the bottom 4% of absolute MoM performance of BKX index.

investment, banks;

Commodity market Report - February 2020

Trade war is officially over but Chinese risks resurfaced from the other side - extreme quarantine measures after coronavirus outbreak in Jan-Feb resulted in significant breakdown in the industrial production chains and construction activity. However monetary and fiscal stimuli quickly reversed negative sentiment and overall risk conditions returned to the high Greed mode with only commodities market kept in risk-off mode. Energy complex was very volatile as its initial sharp drop was lately compensated by OPEC verbal interventions and renewed risk in Libya and Venezuela. Industrial metals fell sharply, but Precious shined brightly with unbelievable bubble in Palladium. Agri commodities were mostly range bound with Cocoa being top performer

Macroeconomic drivers turn to negative as positive developments after the Trade Deal signature and record financial markets levels gave the way to fears of world economic slowdown after the virus outbreak. On the other hand there were not many voices for recession as stimulative monetary policy should provide the cushion. However we think that markets overstated willingness of the Fed to keep on printing and the main risk once again turned to the hawkish surprise when it exits REPO stimulus gambit and the ECB to end QE. 

commodity;